Property and Casualty claims are handled directly by the claims staff of The Church Insurance Companies1 who are dedicated to providing you with top-notch service and information.

1The Church Insurance Company of Vermont, The Church Insurance Company, and The Church Insurance Agency Corporation. 

To Report a Claim

Whenever there is knowledge of an actual claim or potential claim, a report to The Church Insurance Company should be made as soon as possible. Prompt reporting allows us to better serve our clients by quickly initiating the claim process resulting in mitigating the loss and timely resolution of the claim.

If you suffer a major loss, contact our Claims Center:

After Hours/Emergency Claims
Call (800) 223-5705 for instructions on how to reach Cunningham-Lindsey, our main field adjustment/investigation company, for whatever emergency action they believe is necessary to handle the situation.

Sensitive Claims
To report claims of great sensitivity (such as misconduct matters or severe injury), please call the following senior claims personnel:

  • Samuel Carucci, Esq, Vice President, Claims (800) 223-6602, ext. 1348
  • Kenneth Miller, Claims Examiner (800) 223-6602, ext. 1340

Property and Casualty Insurance Disclaimer